Which lubricants are best for pain with penetrationwater vs silicone vs oil? The Womens Health Clinic We did lubes. To find the best water based, silicone, hybrid, and oil based ones, we considered ingredients, texture and thickness, scent and taste, and even used at home pH test strips to look We did lubes. To find the best water based, silicone, hybrid, and oil based ones, we considered ingredients, texture and thickness, scent and taste, and even used at home pH test strips to look Natural Lube: Products and DIYs to Try, Ingredients to Avoid, More